Meryl Streep is The Iron Lady
Is Margaret Thatcher biopic a missed opportunity? Discuss this article
- Picture 1 of 2
If Alison Jackson teamed with Gyles Brandreth to make a musical about Margaret Thatcher, it might look and sound like The Iron Lady, a loud, showy run-through of the life of Britain’s first female prime minister. In its homeland the film has provoked great debate, thrusting the former leader’s legacy into the limelight and attracting legions of angry critics – including current UK prime minister David Cameron. On that level, it’s possible to admire The Iron Lady: we’re all for anything that connects cinema with the real world and gets people talking about the dialogue between the two.
But the film itself, directed by Phyllida Lloyd (Mamma Mia!), is dangerously uncritical of Thatcher and, perhaps worse than that, dramatically unadventurous and weak. Yes, Meryl Streep’s physical presence and voice are spot on and deserve praise, but the film runs with supportive clichés about the former PM and packages the whole thing as camp fun. That might work for a musical based on the songs of Abba. But for the life of one of the world’s most controversial leaders, whatever you think of her politics, it’s insulting to all involved – and, above all, to the cinema-goer.
So what does the film cover? One of its problems is that it tries to cram in everything and, in doing so, recalls little with any depth. The Iron Lady is set in the present as Thatcher, now 86, shuffles about her London home. Her husband Denis (Jim Broadbent) is dead but appears to her regularly as a vision, giving her someone to share her thoughts with. It’s a creaky device, but not as creaky as using old home movies to flash back to holidays with the kids. Flashbacks are the film’s driving force and we see snippets of moments in Thatcher’s life, from working in her father’s shop as a child and losing her first election in 1950 to, as prime minister, deciding to defend the Falkland Islands in 1982 and squabbling with her cabinet.
By imaginatively dramatising the private life of a public figure, a dramatist can suggest a version of the truth and offer opinions to be wrestled with. But there’s none of that in The Iron Lady, or at least in the flashbacks of her life as a politician. Instead, we encounter a series of ‘greatest hits’ from her career, begging the question: what’s the point? Abi Morgan’s script is very nervous of supposition beyond scenes of Thatcher now, tired and half senile. We see her interacting with her daughter, her housekeeper and the ghost of her husband, but little of import is discussed or suggested in these scenes. They leave us only two questions to chew. Has Thatcher’s mind gone? And can she bear to throw out her husband’s clothes? You have to assume that, as burning issues, they’re of limited interest.
The film’s attitude to history is sloppy too. Thatcher’s memories – the flashbacks – appear chronological, but one montage mixes footage of demonstrations by miners in 1984 with a flash of the Brixton riots in 1981. Perhaps the point is that they were all the same to Maggie – but you suspect it’s a case of the filmmakers thinking the difference between a riot and demo is negligible when it comes to kicking up a storm visually.
And what of the politics? Despite Cameron’s protestations, there’s nothing here to trouble Thatcher’s admirers. A section on the Falklands presents her as Churchillian – on the side of the military and refusing to give way to appeasers. More generally, The Iron Lady depicts Thatcher as a progressive warrior in the class and gender war of the late 20th century. ‘Never run with the crowd, Margaret; go your own way,’ her father tells her, and soon we see her fighting for her place in smoky, male-dominated back rooms. No doubt there will be many who take umbrage or offence at the idea of Thatcher as a feminist heroine or a friend of the working man or woman, but at least this element is a provocation. There’s an argument to be swallowed or spat out.
So, what are we left with? A storming impersonation by Streep. Some pleasing operatic choreography by Lloyd. And a feeling that a great opportunity has been squandered.
The Iron Lady is in UAE cinemas now.
Time Out Dubai,
- Reel Cinemas Dubai Marina Mall(8)
- Reel Cinemas The Dubai Mall(19)
- Reel Cinemas The Beach Mall(9)
- VOX Cinemas Mercato Mall(10)
- Novo Cinemas Al Ghurair Centre(7)
- Novo Cinemas Cineplex (near Wafi city)(14)
- VOX Cinemas Deira City Centre(11)
- VOX Cinemas Mirdif City Centre(10)
- VOX Cinemas Mall of the Emirates(18)
- Novo Cinemas Dubai Festival City Mall(15)
- Novo Cinemas Ibn Battuta Mall(22)
Our favourite features
Best afternoon tea in Dubai Cake, sandwiches, tea and lashings of cream at Dubai afternoon teas
Best sushi in Dubai Oishii! Kiree! Sugoi! and welcome to the most enticing sushi in Dubai
Best beach clubs in Dubai Treat yourself to a day of sunbathing and waiter service at the beach
Dubai’s best outdoor bars 25 top places to spend a night under the stars
Best pizzas in Dubai From dial up to dine in we've eaten the best pizzas in Dubai
Dubai's best dim sum Recommended spots to sample this quintessential Chinese dining pastime
Dubai's best buffets Loosen the belt and pile up your plate at these all-you-can eat packages
86 Friday brunches to try Time for brunch? We run through the options - in price order
56 lunch-break buys Start your style revolution from the comfort of your desktop with these ...