The great race

So, which is the fastest way to get around Dubai? We made it our mission to find out... Comments

metrorace_1
© ITP Images

Daisy Carrington: bus
Gayathri Krishnan: car
James Wilkinson: Metro
Laura Chubb: taxi


16.15pm

Bus: I set off in search of the bus stop. Two bus routes go to Mall of the Emirates. Alas, I can only find the stop for the slower one.

Car: I zoom out of the BurJuman carpark – well, after paying Dhs10 for five minutes of parking. Daylight robbery! Off to MoE.

Metro: We’re off! Surely I, with my superior locomotive transportation, will be the winner? Just got to find the station…

Taxi: I casually saunter out of BurJuman, where a long line of vacant cabs eagerly awaits.

16.16pm

Taxi: I’m already on the move. Even sweeter, I spot Daisy slogging to the bus stop in the mid-afternoon heat while I recline in AC bliss. Short straw, anyone?

16.18pm

Car: At a red light between Karama and Mankhool in a sea of cars. Where are all these people going on a Saturday afternoon? A metro train rockets by in all its blue and silver glory. Green light! Whoopee!

Metro: I manage to find my way out of BurJuman after only, er, three minutes.

16.22pm

Metro: In the station, surrounded by people snapping photos; bizarre to think I’ll turn up in the background of someone’s Facebook page. I am directed to the (un-signposted) Jebel Ali line.

Taxi: Having waited at traffic for an age, we hit Sheikh Zayed Road. The road looks pretty clear – very promising.

16.25pm

Car: I glance over to where the Burj Al Arab sits, reminiscing about the day that she was the toast of the town. Seven stars never seems to go out of fashion.

16.28pm

Taxi: I’m drawing level with the Burj Al Arab when, for the first time since we started out, I see a train running parallel to me on the left. Is James on it? I reckon he must be. I start imagining his victory dance and it’s enough to make me consider turning back.

Metro: No victory dance. No train, even; still waiting on the platform.

16.30pm

Bus: I’m sitting on a ledge in front of Spinneys waiting for the bus. Getting sweatier by the minute.

Car: Muppet that I am, I’ve absent-mindedly missed the MoE exit and am now on my way to Media City. Four minutes later I am back on track, my car hungry for a parking spot in the maze that is the MoE parking lot.

Taxi: I’m near Mall of the Emirates metro station now, and the train’s pulling in. I already feel defeated.

16.32pm

Metro: The train arrives after 10 minutes of thumb twiddling. The crowd converges on the doors. I eschew gold class and its leather luxury, for I am a man of the people. Viva la transport revolution!

16.33pm

Taxi: As we pull up at the mall entrance, the meter reads Dhs36. I pay and prepare to leg it to Après.

16.42pm

Metro: The metro gives the perfect viewpoint on The Burj Dubai; thanks to the elevation, you can see it from top to glittering bottom. Sadly, the tuneless, endlessly repeating music playing in the carriages is driving me nuts.

16.45pm

Bus: The bus is here! Finally!

Metro: The scenic views are gone: Al Ghandi Auto is no Burj. The music makes me want to kill someone – possibly everyone.

Taxi: ARRIVED! Having been directed entirely the wrong way three times, I finally find Après. No one’s there. A quick text to James confirms that I won. Woo hoo! I treat myself to a browse in Virgin Megastore.

16.51pm

Car: ARRIVED! Get to Après, but my mini-detour cost me a good six minutes. Damn Laura’s non-digressing, ox-like focus. I demand a do-over.

16.51pm

Metro: We arrive at the station. Everyone remains un-murdered.

17.00pm

Bus: We’re zooming up Sheikh Zayed Road at a good pace, and we pass the Four Points By Sheraton. Maybe this won’t take that long after all.

Metro: The ticket barriers and escalators are overcrowded, so it takes a good six minutes to even get out of the station, and a further three to get into the mall proper.

17.04pm

Metro: ARRIVED! I finally arrive at Après. Third place! Outrage. Good job I don’t pay taxes or I’d ask for them back.

17.15pm

Bus: I pass by an ominous sign pointing to the Al Quoz graveyard. Awesome, we’re already in Al Quoz. The mall’s got to be close.

18.00pm

Bus: I see a sign pointing to Barsha. Seriously, how much further?

18.15pm

Bus: The bus finally stops, letting us out in the middle of nowhere. I could take another bus to the Mall, but I can’t stand waiting any longer. I lurch towards the first cab that passes my way.

18.28pm

Bus: ARRIVED! After a well-deserved swig of water, I admit to catching a cab. They agree that, after two hours on a bus, this is not a punishable offence.

The results:

Winner: taxi (30 minutes; Dhs36)
Second place: car (35 minutes; Dhs10 for parking)
Third place: Dubai Metro (50 minutes; Dhs6.50)
Last place: bus (135 minutes; Dhs4.10)
The result: The road remains the fastest means, but the metro is the cheapest. We’ll see how the four fare again in six months, when roads are busier and the metro system is more complete.

By James Wilkinson
Time Out Dubai, 14 September 2009
Posted by: tolits on 16 Sep ' 09 at 09:25

What is RTA doing on the clamour of majority of the commuters? The USE of the NEW card is VERY INEFFECTIVE. Everyone is complaining since the start of the METRO. I thought, the METRO is a good move and a benefit to commuters but as per observation..its a BURDEN.
I stay in Satwa and whenever I am at the bus station, I see a long line of commuters busy recharging their cards. Some would say, the machine is not functioning...blah..blah..blah..What is this?
And last night, I felt so DISGUSTED when I came to know that drivers are no longer allowed to sell cards so I was forced to go home by taxi. Drivers should have been telling us about this so that we would know what to do. CONFUSING! RTA should do something about this.

Posted by: BananaMan on 15 Sep ' 09 at 07:56

try motorcycle

Posted by: Dan on 15 Sep ' 09 at 07:13

What makes the so called "cheap" Metro even more interesting is that for a family of 4 for a 2-way trip, the cost works out to approx Dhs 52.

And let's not forget that around 5 stations are not yet operational on this route. Add approx 10 mins to the Metro trip once these get working.

So its clear then. Even after paying for Salik, fuel etc,(or even a Taxi), the Metro is : more expensive, much slower, and far less comfortable than using your own car - or even a taxi.

Expect the standard "Dubai Solution" to this : Make cars a LOT more expensive to own & drive and force us to use their Train. It'll be Rentals v/s Freehold all over again. Remember those happy times ?

Posted by: Umar in Dubai on 15 Sep ' 09 at 06:50

Good comparison. It also depends on time of the day. During rush hours metro would be fastest but in the off-peak hours nothing can beat your own car (or taxi). Looking forward to see this again in 6 months.

Posted by: Naseem on 15 Sep ' 09 at 06:03

the car should have won anyway... usually its hard to catch a taxi during busy hours... plus you should keep in mind to calculate fuel and salik and parking when driving in private car. you can also calculate the cost you pay for your car as installments and servicing by stretching the cost over 30 days.

Add your review/feedback

Subscribe to Daily Dubai newsletter

Submit

The Knowledge

Kathmandu calling
Nov 24

flydubai set to launch new flights to Nepal on December 15

French fancy
Nov 24

Emirates will fly to Paris from December 29 - a month earlier than planned

Eid weather looking good
Nov 24

Dubai set for a pleasant Eid weekend to enjoy the outdoors...

Newsletters

Sign up now
EATING OUT GUIDEOut now!

Time Out
Abu Dhabi

Man City V UAE
Manchester City take on the UAE national team

Time Out
Bahrain

25 to try: Cheap eats in Bahrain
Time Out hit the town to find where you can eat for under BD3

Time Out
Doha

England v Brazil
Relive the action from Khalifa Stadium